
I widely consider the ‘Childs Play/Chucky’ franchise to be one of the strongest film series of the slasher genre. As a series they are some of the most consistently entertaining, engaging and interesting films out of the long running slasher characters. But that ISNT to say that the series hasnt had missteps along the way, and three entries in, we finally hit for me, the first entry that I just dont really ‘vibe’ with.
Childs play 3 picks up some years after the events of ‘Childs Play 2’ The Play Pals warehouse and manufacturing area has seemingly been left untouched since the night Kyle, Andy and Chucky fought to the death…But! they’re reopening! and they’re bringing the ‘good guy’ doll kicking and screaming into the 90s. While clearing away debris, they grab the huge mound of moulding plastic that WAS ‘Chucky’ and drag it over a stood pool of wet plastic, dripping an amount of chuckys blood into the vat in the process. They then use this LONG stood pool of blood to create a new line of ‘Good Guy’ dolls…and…well you can guess how Chucky ends up back in this movie.
Andy is now 16 meaning theres been a roughly 9 year jump between the events of ‘Childs Play 2’ and 3…meaning *technically* this film is taking place in the far FAR future of 1998! WOOOOO Spooky…*Ahem* It doesnt feel like 1998…
Anyway, Andy has been bouncing around various homes and found himself drafted into Military school where the teachers are sadistic and weird, the students are sadistic and weird and even the good ones feel a little flat…life isnt going great for Andy…but its about to get worse when Chucky kills the owner of the Playpals company, and using their file on Andy, manages to track him down to the academy…Only, theres a twist.
Chucky mails himself to the acadamy and lands in the mail room where a young cadet named Tyler is asked to take the parcel to Andys room. Tyler sees however that its a Good Guy doll, something he desperately wants…so instead he takes the doll to the armoury and hides the packaging. Chucky bursts out of the parcel and realises what Tylers done…before FURTHER realising that he’s in a new body, and using the rule of ‘He can transfer his soul into the first person he tells his secret to’ he decides to go after Tyler instead while ALSO trying to kill Andy for all the trouble he’s caused him over the years.
Thus, Andy and his new friends must traverse the awful standards of the academy AND the return of a killer doll to save Tyler and bring an end to Chucky once and for all.
Living in the UK, this film has almost always had a bit of a taint to it due to its (VERY loose) connections to the 1993 Jamie Bulger case. But even with the ties, I just never really got on with this film and…there are a few reasons for that.
The script is probably the biggest part of that, whereas the first childs play balanced horror and thriller elements quite successfully, and the 2nd entry mixed light humour, horror and a classic ‘Universal Monsters’ edge to help give it a distinct flavour, ‘Childs Play 3’ is a harsher viewing experience that seems to have a heavy emphasis on horror and a MUCH more aggressive tone across the board.
The tone is much nastier, much more violent and while this could have worked if it was a bit more spread out, its relentless for most of the runtime and felt quite oppressive to me. the tone of the humour is different here, much less broadly funny and much nastier in its punchlines, which didnt really do anything for me, the gore sequences are stronger and go on for WAY longer than previous entries…I found it really offputting for that.
The plot feels thinner too, Andy going to a military academy and Chucky hunting him down inside the academy feels like it could have a LOT of decent potential for story fodder…on paper…But the reality is most of the film feels quite repetative, they have one main event (a paintball capture the flag scenario) thats teased from the 2nd act right the way through to about 15 minutes off the end and other than that and the occasional moment of Andy trying to warn Tyler everything else just feels like blood soaked filler…and not good blood soaked filler.
The film wheezes to make its 90 minute runtime, it feels a good 20 minutes longer than it needed to be, and the act structuring feels a little bit wobbly, slowing down to a crawl in places before snapping off a half hours exposition in 5 minutes. it feels a bit inconsistent, like it maybe needed a further draft or two just to get it really nailed down.
The characters all feel very blunt, they’re either sadist assholes or charismatic archtypes, De Silver is a likeable character, but other than being a love interest for Andy and a sarcastic wise cracker, she doesnt really have much in the way of depth to her character. The same could be said for Whitehurst, who is basically the shy nerdy type who gets bold when the time comes to step up.
its all very predictable, and the lack of depth from the senior cadets or teachers beyond ‘They’re assholes’ is a shame as I feel like there was some real scope here to bring a more complex layer to the film.
The most unfortunate thing about this entry is that it seems to be trying to set up a handover to help carry the franchise into the future. Reframing the film to focus on Tyler, a cadet whos maybe a little bit older than Andy was in the first ‘Childs Play’ while also introducing Desilver to partner up with Andy in taking down Chucky seems to be setting up a 4th entry with Tyler leading and Andy and Desilver backing him up.
At the time, this probably felt like the sensible thing to do…But unfortunately, this would be the last ‘Childs Play’ film for almost 7 years…and when they pick back up with the franchise, they went in a TOTALLY different direction…meaning a lot of whats setup in this film, ultimately ends up not meaning all that much… which doesnt really help this film, not to mention that AS mentioned…this film takes place in 1998, and the next film ALSO takes place in 1998…or 1999 at the latest…soooooo I dont know how the timelines are supposed to work with this thing….but its weird.
For me, this film has a strong 15 minute or so opening, and a strong 15 minute or so finale…more or less everything in between it though I just found a bit dull and unpleasent.
The direction, to me? was also offputting. This is framed much more as a straight horror film and as such the direction is cold, heavy emphasis on showing all the nastiest bits, it emphisises gore over trying to make the rest of the film look interesting, meaning a lot of this movie winds up feeling a bit ‘TV Movie’-esq, a BIG downgrade from what was on offer with ‘Childs Play 2’, its all a bit bland, by the number and barring the opening and the finale, it feels a bit like the director didnt really know how to jazz up a military academy…
Also; I dont feel like they really knew how to work with ‘Chucky’. Its kind of a mix between them redesigning the chucky puppet again and a more limited scope on what they could do. But the puppet here looks noticably cheaper than the last entry, its much more obvious when Chucky is going to move, and when he isnt, the ‘angry’ chucky puppet (for lack of a better descriptor) appears a handful of times and looks rediculous…and I dont feel like they really knew how to make Chucky feel like a well rounded character in this, he’s always in ‘Super evil killer’ mode…which is a real shame because some of the best moments of the previous two entries were when Chucky was just kind of hanging about being funny or calmly talking about how much fun killing is…
Its a bland watching experience not helped by the editing either which is abrasive, full of fast cuts…its aggressive, in your face and makes it hard to really get into for me because it hits you with the fast cuts and overuse of B-roll almost right out of the gate. its all too much. While the cine probably could have had its time to shine in a slower pacing and stronger narrative…here it feels like its been butchered to within an inch of its life. its a grey, drab and flat experience throughout.
As for the performances?…say it with me, ‘Brad Dourif is the lifeblood of this series’ even when the film is generally poor, Dourif swoops in and saves it from total mediocrity. Here? he’s fantastic giving Chucky some of his better aggressive moments and his charisma still shines through…Though, im less happy about them DESPERATELY trying to cram in catchphrases to this entry to try and make them a ‘thing’ (‘Dont fuck with the chuck’ will NEVER be a thing…)
Justin Whalin as Andy is fine, he captures the vibe and feel of the original Andy, gives a decent performance of a traumatized kid once again trying to put to bed his traumas. He’s probably the second strongest performance in this film…Though I would argue if your being upstaged by an animatronic…somethings probably not gone quite right.
Barring Perrey Reeves and Dean Jacobson as Desilver and Whitehurst respectively who are *fine* giving a performance that isnt bad, but didnt really excel in my opinion, the rest of the cast could realistically have been in any late 80s B movie schlock of the time and just about got a pass…Unfortunately; this is a studio picture and AS such has certain expectations to meet…which means in this context, they’re not good. one dimensional, largely barking lines and nothing else, theres little range, little interest and little investment to have in theses characters…which really puts a dampner on proceedings…
Even the soundtrack is loud and aggressive…a cacophony of missed opportunities and synth pangs…To me? it doesnt feel like a ‘Childs Play’ score…it feels like a generic early 90s horror score turned up 20% louder and more obnoxious than it needs to be. I really didnt care for it.
Theres at least 40 good minutes in ‘Childs Play 3’, 15 at the beginning, 15 at the end and 10 dotted out across the middle…but the rest? really wasnt for me. Its just too harsh a movie on every front for what I come to a ‘Childs Play’ film for. If I want excessive gore or violence, I’ll watch ‘Saw’ or ‘Terrifier’. This was a drab and exhausting watching experience and thats a real shame…This isnt one I spin often, I’ve probably seen it about half a dozen times now and while I will say my thoughts on it do improve slightly with every rewatch, I cant ever imaging me getting to a point with this one where i’d positively compare it to the previous entries.
The finale of the ‘Childs Play’ trilogy ends with a bang make no mistake, its just a shame about the hour and 15 that preceeds it…
source https://letterboxd.com/tytdreviews/film/childs-play-3/