
I’ve lost track of how many times i’ve seen ‘The Brain that Wouldnt Die’ in one format or another, I’ve seen it riffed multiple times, remixed, novelised, theatricized, turned into a musical, remastered, remade and everything inbetween. On my bluray copy of ‘Phantasmatapes’ in the ‘Special Features’ they included a reasonble quality upscaled VHS rip of the full film to compliment their remixed take on it. Its the kind of quality you’d find on most ‘public domain’ box sets from the 90s and 2000s, Just; captured from a good source and upscaled for HD TVs…And, with Halloween just around the corner. I figured revisiting the film in the format im most familiar with (the kind shown on TV late night before anyone thought to ACTUALLY present the film as intended) was a fun enough way to kill an hour and 20 as any.
The plots straightforward enough. A genius surgeon has been working secretly on a syrum that allows surgical grafts to perfectly meld to the host with no complications and far less risky surgery to do so. Its a world first. But its having to be conducted in secret because, at this point in time that kind of surgery is seen as essentially a death warrent for anyone who wants to participate, and if it got out to the wider medical community before it was ready to be presented, it would be considered ‘Quackery’ at BEST…and aa possible long jail sentence at worst.
However! its vacation time! So! our surgeon and his young lady wife head off in their open top to live it up good and proper! However, disaster strikes when their car takes a bend incorrectly and the pair are flung from the vehical. The surgeons fine enough, other than being a bit shaken…But the wifes in a real bad way…She’s been decapitated. Thinking quickly, her husband bundles her head up and takes her to a nearby safehouse, where he’s been performing his experiments. And, working with a colleague who’s in on the work. They manage to perfectly preserve her head in a tray of ‘ressurection’ fluid.
Of course, the womans absolutely distraught and begs for death. But her husband refuses, saying he’s going to go and secure a body for her, and when he finds the right one. He’s going to use his miracle fluid to successfully transplant his wifes head onto the new body, and from there life will carry on. Shortly after announcing this, she also discovers a ‘failed’ experiment that still lives on, imprisoned behind a locked and bolted door. It turns out that, whatevers in the fluid allows her to telepathically communicate with the beast behind the door, and the pair begin to plot a mutual desctruction of the lab and themselves. While our surgeon friend hits the streets looking for the right body to connect to his wife. Leading to a firey finale.
I have a real soft spot for this one, its sci-fi horor with a twinge of fantasy and a heaping dose of camp and while I cant say its one of my all time favourites, I do find myself occasionally revisiting it for that monster movie quality I love.
The script isnt overly complex, in fact its a very linear, very one note production that deals with a complex theme in a way that a lot of movies of this time wouldnt really handle it. Most films around this time would have framed the husband as a hero for wanting to save his wife, and the wife would have been MORE than willing to have a new body to continue living with her husband, glossing over the more morbid aspects of the logistics of that.
This film tackles it head on, and its refreshing to see a female lead in a monster movie have both autonomy and a decisive wish that goes against the male leads expectations. They frame the husband as a monster in this movie, because he is. and as such its satisfying to see the discussions on letting go, death and having an opinion that goes against loved ones wishes explored in a more interesting fashion.
The pacing is a little ‘come and go’ sometimes it runs with a real zip, while othertimes it can get a little pedestrian. But theres usually something going on consistently throughout, and while I definitely think we could have lost 10 minutes and gained a tighter production alltogether, I appreciate just how much they cram into that 82 minute runtime.
Tonally; its working with a nice contrast, the campier monster sequences and violence are offset by some genuine pathos and depressing moments. its faily early body horror, and I think it handles itself really well.
Direction wise, we have a striking vision, while I can say that visually the imagery is distinct, the cinematography is a little bit generic for the time. The visuals here are unique for this movie, but the actual technical ability that produces them isnt really out of place with the cine styles of the time, and this slots in relatively well with the ‘Night of the ghouls’ and ‘Mad Monsters’ of the era. Its fine enough, maybe a little overly basic at times and the set dressing is minimal to the point of being almost non existent, but the plot and performances are so powerfull, that its only afterwards you really realise just how sparse and basic the production really was.
Virginia Leith as Jan (in the pan) is an absolute showstopper here, bringing a wide range of emotions and coming across as bizarrely understandable and naturalistic for a literal talking severed head. If you only catch the movie for one reason, her performance is almost certainly it. Contrasting her we have Jason Evers as her partner Bill. a malevolent and ruthless figure who we see slowly descend into demented determined madness across the runtime, with a powerful energy that clashes with Virginias wonderfully. The pair are superb on screen together and again, really lift what could have been a VERY corny film above its station.
‘The Brain that wouldnt die’ is one of those ‘Iconic’ Bmovies of the 50s and 60s, maybe lesser thought about than the larger studio funded pics, but a textbook example of the genre and a great starting point for people looking to dig into the lesser known/affectioned titles. Definitely worth your time, especially around the spooky season. Its a quick, fun and slightly messy movie thats got a heart of gold!
source https://letterboxd.com/tytdreviews/film/the-brain-that-wouldnt-die/








